Showing posts with label fire department. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fire department. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 25, 2012

"Boogyman" and the Design Review Board changes meeting date

Hi All,
Design Review Board meeting changed to THURSDAY, JULY 26 @ 9 AM.
Is this to take the place of the cancelled Aug. 1 scheduled meeting?  When the change in meeting date is moved forward of the cancelled date...who expects that?  The change should come after the cancelled date.  Egad.

Well, I suppose the notice of the CHANGE in the day and time for the Design Review Board was posted on the bulletin board at the Township Hall lobby to make this "legal", but how many of you check that bulletin board daily?  I didn't look.  There is a township website.  It could be posted there on the "home" page informing the public of a change in meeting date.  Why the change of day and time for this meeting? I just happened to find this meeting notice on the website this morning.

However, let's take a closer look at the DRB agenda....the Maple Theater and the Township Fire Station adjacent to the theater.  

Some history:
Both are adjacent to the vacant bank building that the shopping center owner at Maple and Telegraph wants to change the zoning  from O-1 to B-2.....with NO "mentioned" tenant in mind.  The O-1 property that has been PROTECTED since 1962 from commercial development.  The zoning change is not only the bank building, but the entire parcel of property that is over one acre in size that would be rezoned.

That zoning change issue has been forwarded by the Planning Commission to the Board of Trustees for a vote.  It will be a public hearing at a future Board of Trustees meeting.  Where is the legal notice of the day and time for that hearing?  There should be 15 day noticing.  It should be on the township website under "legal notices".  Who knows?  You are just the taxpayer.

The Planning Commission mentioned that since no one bothered to come to their public hearing on Monday, July 16, it must mean that all the residents are OK with the issue to change the property to a commercial use.  Of course, someone was there to speak to the issue.  I was in the audience and I spoke for maintaining the zoning of O-1 to protect the adjacent residential property , but Mr. Mintz indirectly referred to me (and anyone else with similar opinions) as the "boogyman" ...scaring people.... because I correctly stated that the property could then have a fast food restaurant and/or be redeveloped with other uses such as a mini strip mall.  There are many uses including another restaurant with a liquor license open until later in the evening in a B-2 zoning. The Maple Theater could acquire the vacant bank building.  The adjacent Maple Theater has an "entertainment" permit as well as the liquor license permit. Perhaps the owners want to expand their business plan.  The property is over an acre and could accommodate  many B-2 uses.

It was obvious to me that the planning department of the township is working toward facilitating the change in zoning by the responses given to the Planning Board questions.  You won't read that in the minutes or see a video of the meeting...township refuses, so far, to tape and archive video recordings of the Planning Commission or the Zoning Board of Appeals or the Design Review Board meetings.  If you were there, you might come to that conclusion like I did.

The residents at Woodward and Square Lake have a Tim Horton restaurant adjacent to them.  The property was B-2....and P-1.  The Tim Horton restaurant was put in the area of what was the parking lot area of the former B-2 use.  That single piece of property  now has 2 businesses...Tim Horton AND the Rusty Bucket restaurant.    The P-1 parking adjacent in this location could also change.  Must be the "boogyman" talking again.

What issues do the recently permitted Maple Theater with a liquor license and the adjacent Township Fire Station need?   Something that only the three elected leaders that make up the Design Review Board on a special day and time will most likely hear?  At a public meeting that is not video archived for the record?  At a public meeting where there will most likely be a final decision made?

For the Maple Theater it may be just the "revision" of the facade as to the type of brick, or the number of windows.....something that won't make a lot of difference to the neighborhood.  Then again, perhaps the facade change is the configuration of the "outdoor" seating area.  Don't know the answer.

The Township Fire Station issue is about a fence.  Privacy fence. Will this decision be made at this meeting or will the issue go before the Zoning Board of Appeals....like most fence issues?  Are they requesting a fence higher than 4 ft.?  Are they getting their fence in place in anticipation of protecting them from the possible noise of a future B-2 commercial use?  Don't know the answer.  Must be the "boogyman" talking again.

If the Township public meetings all had "board packets" with the details of the issue to be discussed posted on the website along with the agenda, a lot of guessing could be eliminated.  

Note:  The August 1 meeting of the Design Review Board is cancelled.


Design Review Board Agenda
CHARTER TOWNSHIP OF BLOOMFIELD
DESIGN REVIEW BOARD
Thursday, July 26, 2012 at 9:00 a.m.
Bloomfield Township Auditorium
I. Attendance
II. Approval of Minutes:
    A. Approval of the Design Review Board Minutes of July 18, 2012
III. New Items:

A. Façade Changes:
1. 4135 W. Maple Rd. – Maple Theater – Façade Revision


B. Site Improvements:
1. 4151 W. Maple Rd. – Fire Station No. 3 – Privacy Fencing



IV. General Business:
   A. Recent Design Review Board Approvals
   B. Next Meeting Date – Wednesday, August 15, 2012
   (The August 1, 2012 Meeting has been cancelled)

C. Public Comment

V. Adjournment


Saturday, July 7, 2012

MONDAY, JULY 9 @ 7 PM Board of Trustees

Hi All,
Monday, July 9, 2012  Board of Trustees meeting at Township Hall @ 7 PM.  Or, you may watch the meeting on Comcast Cable channel 15  at that same day and time or stream it live on your computer at the township web link.  As ALWAYS....please read the PDF BOARD PACKET for details the township wishes to share on each agenda item.




Agenda #2:  nothing in the board packet....is this ANOTHER  Assistant Fire Chief, or did the previous assistant fire chief retire?  I see it as just more TOP HEAVY at the Fire Department management and one way to give raises while claiming wages are frozen.   The annual report for 2011 should be posted HERE on the township website once it is accepted and approved by the trustees.

PUBLIC HEARINGS:  Agenda #4 and #5 
...another word that means the township is at the final stage of these issues and they are going to pass the project no matter what the public says...if tradition holds.


This ordinance was recently REVIEWED by the township attorney because it was a discussed ordinance issue when considering the ML Restaurant at Maple and Lahser.  At this earlier discussion, this ordinance was a problem to considering this location.


The township attorney NOW ruled that if the "shopping center" was in existence prior to 2006....you can put as many liquor licensed businesses as close as you want in that shopping center.  However, earlier in the year, it was interpreted that you can NOT put a NEW RESTAURANT with a liquor license closer than 250 feet to another restaurant with a liquor license.  I would guess that would be to protect a rather large investment in the township by a business from excessive competition within 250 feet with the same kind of liquor license business.

FYI:  there is another restaurant with a liquor license in this shopping center already: the Honey Tree Grille....and it is closer than the 250 feet.  This proposed ML Restaurant should not be permitted based on this ordinance.  However, the township had a recent "reinterpretation" of this ordinance....especially so this ML Restaurant would "comply".   Have you noticed that the township has lately been in the liquor license distribution business? ....giving out many licenses to restaurants that are closer than 250 feet to each other?  The SW corner of Maple and Telegraph has quite a few new liquor licenses granted. 

Agenda item #4....see a previous blog by me on this item archived on this blog page to the right:   http://bloomfieldtwphappenings.blogspot.com/2012/06/tuesday-june-12-7-pm-zoning-board-of.html


Agenda item #5...see a previous blog by me on this item archived on this blog page to the right:
http://bloomfieldtwphappenings.blogspot.com/2012/06/618-7-pm-more-liquor-at-se-lahsermaple.html

Please read my comments about similar requests Agenda # 6 and Agenda # 8  below on DONATIONS by the township to these organizations.

AGENDA # 6..... BBCC......I do NOT believe there should be a donation of public tax money by the township to this organization.  The agenda does not mention how much they are requesting.  Here is their website and see the list of their board of directors below.

Pages 64-67 of the board packet for this meeting give information that indicate only 3 municipalities make donations to this group:  Beverly Hills for $1200; Birmingham for $3000; and Bloomfield Township for $10,000  (formerly given $17,500)  and notice that the City of Bloomfield Hills gives zero.  Why is the Township so generous with taxpayer money?  Is it because the Supervisor is always also on the Board of Directors? and another trustee is always also on the BBCC Board?  I would say this is a CONFLICT OF INTEREST  and taxpayer monies should  NOT be given to this organization.

Another reason I say NO to giving this organization money is the amount of money spent for Executive Director: $44,000;  Youth Coordinator: $29,900; Office Administrator: $8594; another Executive Director? : $11,000; and payroll taxes: $8000.  Plus more administrative costs:  almost half of their budget.

The schools give money...  While this organization may be beneficial to the community...the taxpayers are ALREADY making indirect contributions through the school taxes and tuition money from the schools that participate and donate in the organization and the events. Why double dip the taxpayers?
  
Here is the BBCC list of directors.  Leo Savoie and Corrine Khederian are Township Board members and Kirt Bowden is an employee of the township.
Board of Directors
Executive Committee


Ingrid Day,
President
Trustee, Bloomfield Hills School Board
Cheryl LaKritz,
Vice President (Bloomfield)

Dr. Peter Muller,
Vice President (Birmingham)
Center for Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine
Kathleen Jenkins,
Treasurer
Jenkins, Magnus, Volk & Carroll, CPAs
Leo Savoie,
Member at Large
Supervisor, Bloomfield Township
Robert Sack,
Member at Large
Birmingham Area Senior Citizen Council


Board of Directors


Richard Astrein,
Owner
Astrein's Creative Jewelers
Kirt Bowden,
Chief of Police
Bloomfield Township Police Dept.
Erin Brown,
Co-president
Youth Action Board (YAB), junior, Seaholm High School
Liz Csizmadia,
Caseworker
Birmingham Youth Guidance
The Honorable Diane D’Agostini,
Judge
48th District Court
Christine DiPilato,
Associate Principal

Lahser High School
Liz FellowsBloomfield Hills Schools parent
Corinne Khederian,
Director of District Affairs
Office of State Senator John Pappageorge
Kelsey McClear,
Co-president
Youth Action Board (YAB), junior, Seaholm High School
Rev. Chad Oyer,
Associate Pastor of Student Ministries
First United Methodist Church Birmingham


Jason Rubel,
Principal
East Hills Middle School
Lou Ruggirello,
Associate Principal
Andover High School
Marcia Wilkinson,
Director of Community Relations
Birmingham Public Schools
Sherree Wilson,
Crisis Intervention Counselor
Groves & Seaholm High Schools


AGENDA #8 is a similar community organization called BBFA.

From the Board Packet pages 70-78  can be found this list of their board of directors and their budget.  Notice that there are NO members of the Township leadership found on this board. The request for donation is $2000 however, it is difficult to determine the level of commitment dollar wise from our neighboring communities.   I do not feel that taxpayer dollars should be donated to non-profits...especially ones that operate out of the Bloomfield Hills schools...while the township REPRESENTS  families from 3 other school district communities and collects taxes from them.